This extended abstract represents a summary introduction to a work in progress, which will culminate in a publication and exhibition at The Los Angeles County Museum of Art in 2018. It briefly outlines our discoveries and interpretations, which will be more fully presented, referenced and discussed in the forthcoming catalog.
This presentation is available for download in PDF format.
- Tony Berlant, Artist
- Evan M. Maurer, PhD
Director Emeritus, The Minneapolis Institute of Arts
- Christine VanPool, PhD
Director of Undergraduate Studies and
Associate Professor, Archaeology, University of Missouri
- Thomas Wynn, PhD
Distinguished Professor, Department of Anthropology and
Center for Cognitive Archaeology
University of Colorado, Colorado Springs
The Mimbres culture is named for the Mimbres valley of what is now New Mexico, where a relatively small pueblo social group developed a unique set of artistic traits that reached a “classic period” between AD 1000-1130. The hallmark of Mimbres art is black and white painted ceramic bowls of extraordinary aesthetic and artistic quality.
Primarily, the exhibition and catalog will focus on our interpretation of the paintings themselves. Paintings on Mimbres bowls have generally been divided into two categories: figurative depictions of their natural world (including narrative “story bowls”) and geometrics. However, our extensive research has allowed us to recognize that almost all motifs found on Mimbres bowls can be read as abstract references to trance-state visual experiences, some with direct reference to the natural world, others generated in the brain (entoptic). We thus argue that any of these so-called “geometric” bowls can be deciphered, either as abstractions of natural elements (such as flowers or moths), and/or as brain-generated entoptic shapes and visions experienced while in a trance state, which was in turn induced by the ingestion of psychoactive plants.
Of particular importance to this process was datura, a flowering plant with potent hallucinogenic properties that was utilized for vision quests throughout the Southwest and greater Mesoamerica. Datura still grows on Mimbres archaeological sites today, and was the most powerful mind altering drug used by the Mimbres. As we will demonstrate, Mimbres artists painted – in abstracted form – various aspects of datura, from its seedpods and first blossoming to the final withering of the flower. They also painted the principal pollinators of datura (hawk moths), and the visions associated with ingesting datura. Other plants with mind-altering properties are also depicted. However, datura is the only flower that is depicted in its various morphing configurations.
Significantly the central food plants; corn, beans and squash are never depicted. The reason for this omission could be that these basic food plants were not part of the trance state process that is the central theme of Mimbres painting.
Our findings are based on research supported by the Mimbres Foundation since 1976, as well as the Janss Foundation, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, Thomas Weisel, Richard Fredericks and Laura Stearns. We have employed a variety of perspectives offered by distinguished scholars in our discussions, including Mesoamerican and Southwestern archaeologists, ethnographers, neurologists, artists and art historians. We also took high-resolution and time-lapse photographs of plants and blossoms to provide insights into datura’s significance as a major agent in Mimbres art.
Datura seedpod effigies have been found at archaeological sites throughout the Southwest (Figure 2). Datura flowers open at night, the white blossoms unfurling as if alive, until they are wide open and ready for pollination. Figures 5 – 12 illustrate how, especially when seen in sequence, even the most highly abstracted depictions of datura blossoms can be identified on painted Mimbres bowls.
Figures 1 – 4. (click to enlarge)
Figure 5 shows a datura blossom that is just beginning to unfurl. Figure 6 depicts this early stage of the opening flower and surrounding leaves. The circular shape of the flowers simultaneously reference the spiral, a basic entoptic 4 form. It is significant that the bowl is not circular. Most bowls are only slightly off center. However, many Mimbres bowls seem constructed as if mimicking both the floppy and irregular shape of the datura blossom and the morphing trance state portal. The painting in these vessels are carefully conceived to fit the irregular shape of the bowl.)
Figures 5 – 9. (click to enlarge)
In addition to many other stages of the datura flower’s life cycle, we have also identified representations of the datura stamen, and a number of other plants/flowers including: desert tobacco, evening primrose, sunflowers, agave, prickly pear, and cotton. These will be illustrated in the forthcoming publication.
Figures 10 – 12. (click to enlarge)
Fig. 12 demonstrates how the abstraction of the datura blossom is often used as a format, in this case for the depiction of two deer.
Hawk moth elements
Hawk moths are the principal pollinators of datura, furthermore; their entire lifecycle (from egg, larva, and pupa-stage through to fully developed adult moth) may be spent with the datura plant. There is no doubt that Mimbres people were keen observers and were fully aware of the symbiotic relationship between datura and hawk moth and associated the moth with the powerful effects contained in the plant. This key insight has allowed us to recognize many painted Mimbres “geometric” motifs as abstracted depictions of patterns seen on hawk moth bodies (whether in the larval, pupal, or moth state).
Figures 13 – 14. (click to enlarge)
Figure 13 shows a five-spotted hawk moth with its proboscis extended to feed on the nectar of a datura flower. We believe that the distinctive pattern on the side of its body was interpreted and abstracted by Mimbres artists to become a checkerboard pattern, a common motif in Mimbres painting (as seen on Figures 14 and 18). In Figure 14, the overall appearance of the hawk moth is abstracted. Using a particular pattern in a different location in abstracted images is a common occurrence, as shown on this bowl where the checkerboard pattern is moved from the body onto the wings. Elongating the wings is another recurring convention as seen in Figure 18.
Some painted patterns are representations of commonly experienced entoptic shapes (Figure 16). We specifically argue that the association between hawk moth and datura would have been reinforced by the fact that certain patterns found on hawk moths, in particular zigzag lines (Figure 15), are themselves entoptic shapes commonly seen while in a datura-induced trance state.
Figures 15 – 16. (click to enlarge)
The literature on psychoactive substances and hallucinatory experiences (which we explore in greater detail in the forthcoming catalog) show that many of the most widely reported entoptic hallucinogenic effects and visions produced by ingesting datura are consistent with the motifs seen on the bowls; most importantly a white circular tunnel, a spinning field of vision, entoptic shapes such as zigzag lines, triangles, nested squares, and concentric circles.
Story bowls: new interpretations through the lens of datura
To clarify how our interpretations differ from existing scholarship, we here present some examples that are representative of the type of analysis we will present in the exhibition catalogue.
Figures 17 – 19. (click to enlarge)
The bowls in Figures 17 and 18 appear to portray transformative shamanistic experiences. The painting in Figure 18 incorporates hawk moth wings (compare to Figure 14) and the pointed end of the hawk moth abdomen into a recognizable human figure. The painting in Figure 17 depicts a hawk moth with its proboscis extended and a small human riding on its back. The moth and its rider are off-center, giving the impression that they are in flight. Shamans traveling in the spirit world commonly report flying, and often have a tutelary creature that will help them navigate the dangers of the spirit world. This may be a depiction thereof.
Aside from decoding many of the “geometric” designs in Mimbres art, our insights also allow a new deeper interpretation of figurative Mimbres paintings, including the narrative scenes on so-called “story bowls”. On the basis of our interpretation, these figurative scenes are likely to be both individualized and culturally mandated trance state visions, taking place in a white circular space which, as will be explained in the forthcoming publication, is so often reported in trance state visions (the “trance state tunnel”). We also explore in more detail the role the bowls themselves would have played in structuring and dictating the Mimbres trance state experience. Once we had settled on a neuroaesthetics approach, we invited one of the founders of the perspective, renowned cognitive neuroscientist Prof. V Ramachandran of the University of California, San Diego, who visited with us in Santa Monica on numerous occasions, and confirmed the appropriateness of our approach.
Figures 20 – 23. (click to enlarge)
As mentioned, Mimbres artists represented several life stages of the hawk month’s development. The death and rebirth-like process of the hawk moth as it emerges after pupating, transformed from its caterpillar form into a moth, would have been important. In Figure 20 we see the hawk moth larva (“horn worm”) with its segmented, tube-like body and what appears to be a head with mouth, horn, and eye, but which is actually its tail end. Figure 21 shows the adult hawk moth emerging from the chrysalis, its front legs kicking as it breaks free of the hard shell.
Many details in the painting on the bowl in Figure 22 have clear visual connections to the hawk moth in its larval and chrysalis stages, and we thus interpret the central figure of the painting as a large, mythic hawk moth larva, likely involved in a ritual of shamanic transformation, aided by two helpers. The tail of the chrysalis is suggestive of the end of a rattlesnake’s tail, however, the ovoids with dots on the neck reference the shapes that appear on the lower abdomen of the hawk moth’s body. (see Figures 19, 22 and 23). Ambiguous depictions with possible multiple meanings are often present. The usual forward curving horn of the larva (see Figure 20) is here paired with another that curves backwards. This may depict the moment when the antennae of the hawk moth break out of the hard chrysalis case as seen in Figure 21.
Our interpretation of this scene is that the ingestion of datura transported a shaman into trance state, where he merged with the mythic hawk moth larva. The transformative power of the hawk moth (to transform itself from a caterpillar into a moth) would have been central to the Mimbres conceiving of and painting this scene.
A fourth enigmatic figure below the larva lies in a static pose. He may be dead or in a transformative state that fits the whole narrative. We may be seeing four different figures, or more likely, one figure shown in sequential narrative action. Multiple images of one figure in different stages seems to be a recurring depiction in Mimbres narrative story bowls.
The painting in Figure 23 depicts another combination hawk moth larva and shaman. While this creature has often been associated with the plumed serpent of Mexican mythology, we argue that the forward turning horn is that of a hawk moth larva (Figure 20), and the tail with six ovoid forms with a dot in the middle is a direct reference to the dotted ovoids on the bottom of the hawk moth’s body. These dots are also referenced between the legs of the Shaman in Figure 18.
In both Figures 22 and 23, the fact that the figures are painted within a white circular space with concentric circles at the periphery – a very common entoptic manifestation of being in a trance state – emphasize the supernatural character of the scene. We argue that the white circular space of the bowl’s interior is the opening of the trance state portal between the spirit world and the mundane world. The open portal allows the shaman to safely return from his interaction with the mythic hawk moth larva.
After we recognized the centrality of datura, we found that three individuals, the late Paul T. Kay, Lisa Huckell and Christine VanPool had earlier made this connection. In 2005 Paul T. Kay presented a poster presentation that recognized the presence of datura at Mimbres, Casa Grandes and Sityakti pueblos. He was the first to publish a datura related image, in this case a representation of a hawk moth larva. We found that Huckell and VanPool had come to appreciate the importance of datura in 2006, and identified a bowl as depicting the exploded datura seedpod. Although she did not publish a photograph of this bowl, it was the first recognition of the depiction of the datura seedpod.
Another aspect of the catalog will expand upon an idea that Berlant first published in 1973, which is that certain groups of bowls can be assigned to individual Mimbres artists. There is in our minds no doubt that there were a very small number of Mimbres master artists. Figures 11 and 12, for example, we believe are two works by the same painter.
In all native cultures of the Americas, art is rarely art for art’s sake: each motif and painted element has meaning. The forthcoming publication begins to decode the visual information on Mimbres bowls. Beyond our realization that Mimbres art is the world seen through the lens of datura, the most significant and unexpected insight is the realization that the so-called “geometrics” were not non-objective inventions, but rather abstracted depictions of flowers, most commonly datura, and the brain-generated entoptic forms associated with its ingestion.
Furthermore, the overtly figurative aspect of Mimbres painting has no parallels in any of the surrounding traditions. Painting datura flowers in carefully observed sequence, may have led to a naturalistic narrative style in the depictions of animals and people.
Scholars have long recognized parallels in the motifs and patterns of painted ceramics between Mimbres and surrounding cultures. Our identification of these motifs as abstracted but readable images thus extends beyond the Mimbres tradition itself, and allows us to interpret some of the art of other SW cultures as datura-related.
Beyond what is addressed in this paper the “Decoding Mimbres” exhibition catalog will include our exploration of Mimbres painting as art.
Mimbres Project Consultants
- Julia Burtenshaw Postdoctoral Curatorial Fellow Art of the Ancient Americas LACMA
- Damon Cirulli Director – Cinematographer
- Jared Diamond Professor of Geography UCLA
- Christopher Donnan Professor Emeritus, Anthropology, UCLA
- Richard Ehrlich Fine Art Photographer Professor Emeritus, UCLA
- John Gowlett Professor, Archaeology, Classics and Egyptology University of Liverpool
- Alan Grinnell Distinguished Professor, Integrative Biology and Physiology, Brain Research Institute, UCLA
- John Hirx Senior Objects Conservator and Head of Objects Conservation, Los Angeles County Museum of Art
- Siegfried Lodwig, Los Alamos, NM
- Peter Nabokov Professor, American Indian Studies and World Arts and Cultures, UCLA
- V.S. Ramachandran Director of the Center for Brain and Cognition and Distinguished Professor with the Psychology Department and Neurosciences Program at the University of California, San Diego, and Adjunct Professor of Biology at the Salk Institute
- Matthew H. Robb Chief Curator, Fowler Museum at UCLA
- Bill Schenck Artist
- Lili Singer Director of Special Projects and Adult Education, Payne Institute for Native Plants and Seeds
- Laura Stearns Art Historian
- Aisha Ayers
- Jacqueline LaPierre
- Asher Price
Adams, E. Charles. 1991: The Origin and Development of the Pueblo Katsina Cult Tucson, Arizona: The University of Arizona Press.
Adams, Karen R., and Mollie S. Toll. 2000: Tobacco Use, Ecology, and Manipulation in the Prehistoric and Historic Southwest United State. In Tobacco Use by Native North Americans: Sacred Smoke and Silent Killer, edited by Joseph C. Winter, pp. 143-170. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.
Ashmore, Wendy. 1991: Site-Planning Principles and Concepts of Directionality among the Ancient Maya. Latin American Antiquity 2(3): 199-226.
Bettison, Cynthia Ann, Roland Shook, Randy Jennings, and Dennis Miller. 1999: New Identifications of Naturalistic Motifs on Mimbres Pottery. In Sixty Years of Mogollon Archaeology: Papers from the Ninth Mogollon Conference, Silver City, New Mexico, 1996, edited by Stephanie M. Whittlesey, pp. 119-125. Tucson: SRI Press.
Brody, J. J. 1977: Mimbres Painted Pottery. Santa Fe, NM: School for Advanced Research Press.
Brody, J.J., and Swentzell, Rina. 1996: To Touch the Past: The Painted Pottery of the Mimbres People. Hudson Hills Press, New York.
Brodzky, Anne Trueblood, Rose Danesewich, Nick Johnson (editors) 1977: Stones, Bones and Skin; Ritual and Shamanic Art. Toronto, Canada: The Society for Art Publications
Carr, Patricia. 1979: Mimbres Mythology. University of Texas, El Paso.
Carrasco, Davíd. 1990: Religions of Mesoamerica: Cosmovision and Ceremonial Centers. Long Grove, Ill: Waveland Press, Inc.
Claus, E.P., Tyler, V.E.,Brady, L.R. 1970: Pharmacognosy. Philadelphia: Lea and Feviger.
Cleversley, Keith. Entheology.com, January 1, 2002. Datura Innoxia – Toloache
Clottes, Jean and Lewis-Williams, David. 1998: The Shamans of Prehistory: Trance and Magic in the Painted Caves. New York: Harry N. Abrams Inc.
Coolidge, Frederick L. and Wynn, Thomas. 2009: The Rise of Homo sapiens: The Evolution of Modern Thinking. West Sussex, U.K.: Wiley-Blackwell.
Coolidge, Frederick L. and Wynn, Thomas. 2009: The Rise of Homo sapiens: The Evolution of Modern Thinking. West Sussex, U.K.: Wiley-Blackwell.
Cosgrove, Cornelius Burton. 1932: The Swarts Ruin: A Typical Mimbres Site in Southwestern New Mexico; Report of the Mimbres Valley expedition, seasons of 1924-1927, vol. 15, issue 1. Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archeology and Ethnology. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University.
De Beaune, Sophie A., Coolidge, Frederick L. and Wynn, Thomas, editors. 2009: Cognitive Archaeology and Human Evolution. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Devereux, Paul. 2008: The Long Trip: A Prehistory of Psychedelia. Brisbane, Australia: Daily Grail Publishing.
Di Peso, Charles C., Rinaldo, John B. and Fenner, Gloria J. 1974: Casa Grandes: A Fallen Trading Center of the Gran Chichimeca. Amerind Foundation. Publication No. 9, Vols. 1-8.
Dowson, Thomas and Lewis-Williams, David. 1989: Images of Power: Understanding San Rock Art. Western Cape Province, South Africa: Southern Book Publishers.
Eliade, M. 1964: Shamanism: Archaic Techniques of Ecstasy. Princeton University Press, Bollingen Foundation.
Fewkes, J. W. 1923: Designs on Prehistoric Pottery from the Mimbres Valley, New Mexico. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 74(6), Washington, D.C.
Fogelin, L. 2007: Inference to the Best Explanation: A Common and Effective Form of Archaeological Reasoning. American Antiquity 72:603-626.
Gilpin, Patricia, Thompson, Marc and Kristina Wyckoff. 2014: Ritual Change and the Distant: Mesoamerican Iconography, Scarlet Macaws, and Great Kivas in the Mimbres Region of Southwestern New Mexico. American Antiquity 79 (1): 90-107.
Grant, Verne, and Karen A. Grant. 1983: Behavior of Hawk moths on flowers of Datura meteloids. Botanical Gazette (144): 280–284.
Hays-Gilpin, Kelley A., and Jane H. Hill. 1999: The Flower World in Material Culture: An Iconographic Complex in the Southwest and Mesoamerica. Journal of Anthropological Research 55:1-37.
Hays-Gilpin, Kelley A., Laurie D. Webster, and Polly Schaafsma
2004 The Iconography of Tie-dye Textiles in the Ancient Americas. Cosmos 20:33-56.
Hegmon, Michelle, and Wenda R. Trevathan
1996: Gender, Anatomical Knowledge, and Pottery Production: Implications of an Anatomically Unusual Birth Depicted on Mimbres Pottery from
Southwestern New Mexico. American Antiquity 61:747-754.
Hegmon, Michelle, and Stephanie Kulow. 2005: Painting as Agency, Style as Structure: Innovations in Mimbres Pottery Designs from Southwest New Mexico. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 12:313–334.
Hill, Jane H. 1992: The flower world of Old Uto-Aztecan. Journal of Anthropological Research 48:117-144.
Huckell, Lisa W., and Christine S. VanPool. 2006: Toloatzin and shamanic journeys exploring the ritual role of sacred datura. In Religion of the Prehispanic Southwest. Archaeology of Religion Series, edited by Christine S. VanPool, Todd L. VanPool, and David A. Phillips, pp.147–164. Altamira, Walnut Creek.
Huffman, T. N. 2004: The Aim and Practice of Archaeology. The South African Archaeological Bulletin 59(180): 66–69.
Jett, S. C., and P. B. Moyle. 1986: The Exotic Origins of Fishes Depicted on Prehistoric Mimbres Pottery from New Mexico. American Antiquity 51:688–720.
Kabotie, F. 1982: Designs from the Ancient Mimbrenos with a Hopi Interpretation. Northland Press, Flagstaff.
Kay, Paul T. 2005: Ancient Voices, Murals and Pots Speak, Datura. A Poster Presentation at the 70th Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, Salt Lake City, Utah.
Kelley, J. H., and M. P. Hanen. 1988: Archaeology and the Methodology of Science. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press.
Kelley, J. H. 2001: A Middle-of-the-Road View of Archaeology. In Examining the Course of Southwestern Archaeology: The Durango Conference, September 1995, edited by D. A. Phillips, Jr., and L. Sebastian, pp. 129–144. , Albuquerque: New Mexico Archaeological Council Special Publication 3.
LeBlanc, Steven A. 1983: The Mimbres People: Ancient Pueblo Painters of the American Southwest. London: Thames and Hudson.
LeBlanc, Steven A., Kreisman, Lori S. Cobb, Brian M. Kemp, Francis E. Smiley, Shawn W. Carlyle, Anna N. Dhody, and Thomas Benjamin. 2007: Quids and Aprons: Ancient DNA from Artifacts from the American Southwest. Journal of Field Archaeology 23: 161–175.
Leonard, Robert D. 2003: Essential Tensions. In Essential Tensions in Archaeological Method and Theory, edited by T. L. VanPool and C. S. VanPool, pp. 143–152. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.
Lewis-Williams, J. David, and Dowson, T.A. 1988: The signs of all times. Current Anthropology 29:201–245.
Lewis-Williams, David. 2004: The Mind in the Cave: Consciousness and The Origins of Art. London: Thames & Hudson Ltd.
Lévi-Strauss, C. 1968: The Effectiveness of Symbols. Republished in Reader in Comparative Religion: An Anthropological Approach, edited by W. A. Less and E. Z. Vogt, pp. 318-327.
McKenna, Terence and McKenna, Dennis. 1993: The Invisible Landscape: Mind, Hallucinogens, and the I Ching. New York: HarperCollins.
Moerman, Daniel E. 1998: Native American Ethnobotany. University of California, Los Angeles; 194-195.
Morton, Julia F. 1977: Major Medicinal Plants: Botany, Culture, and Uses. Springfield, Illinois: Thomas.
Moulard, Barbara. 1984: Within the Underworld Sky: Mimbres Ceramic Art in Context. Santa Fe, NM: Twelve Trees Press.
Munson, Marit. 2000: Sex, Gender, and Status: Human Images from the Classic Mimbres. American Antiquity 65:127–143.
Nelson, Margaret C. and Hegmon, Michelle. 2010: Mimbres Lives and Landscapes Santa Fe, New Mexico: School for Advanced Research Press.
Pearson, James L. 2002: Shamanism and the Ancient Mind: A Cognitive Approach to Archaeology. Walnut Creek, California: Altamira Press.
Powell-Marti, Valli S., Gilman, Patricia A. editors. 2006: Mimbres Society. Tucson, Arizona: The University of Arizona Press.
Ramachandran, V. S. 2011: The Telltale Brain: A Neuroscientist’s Quest for What Makes Us Human. New York: W. W. Norton & Company Inc. NY.
Riley, Carroll L. 2005: Becoming Aztlan: Mesoamerican Influence in the Greater Southwest, A.D. 1200-1500. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake
Russell, Frank. 1908: The Pima Indians. In The 26th Annual Report of the Bureau of American Ethnology. Government Printing Office, Washington.
Sacks, Oliver. 2013: Hallucinations. New York: Vintage Books.
Schultes, Richard E., Hofmann and C. Rätsch. 2001: Plants of the Gods: Their Sacred, Healing, and Hallucinogenic Powers. Rochester, Vermont: Healing Arts Press.
Shaffer, Brian S., Karen M. Gardner, and Joseph F. Powell. 1999: Sexual Division of Labor in the Prehistoric Puebloan Southwest as Portrayed by Mimbres Potters. In Sixty Years of Mogollon Archaeology: Papers from the Ninth Mogollon Conference, Silver City, New Mexico, 1996, edited by Stephanie M. Whittlesey, pp. 113–118. SRI Press, Tucson, Arizona.
Siegel, Ronald K. 1989: Intoxication: Life in Pursuit of Artificial Paradise. New York: E.P. Dutton.
Siegel, Ronald K., and Louis J. West (editors). 1975: Hallucinations: Behavior, Experience and Theory. New York: John Wiley and Sons.
Sorell, Tom. 1991: Scientism: Philosophy and the Infatuation with Science. New York: Routledge.
Teague, Lynn. 1999: Textiles and Prehistory. Archaeology Southwest 13(4): 1-4.
Thompson, M. 1999a Knife-wing: A Prominent Mesoamerican, Mimbres, and Pueblo Icon. In Sixty Years of Mogollon Archaeology: Papers from the Ninth Mogollon Conference, Silver City, New Mexico 1996, edited by Stephanie M. Whittlesey, pp. 145–150. SRI Press, Tucson, Arizona.
Thompson, M. 1999b Mimbres Iconology: Analysis and Interpretation of Figurative Motifs. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Archaeology, University of Calgary, Calgary.
Townsend, Richard F., Kokrda, Ken, Moulard, Barbara L. 2005: Casas Grandes and the Ceramic Art of the Ancient Southwest. The Art Institute of Chicago, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.
van Nieukerken, Eric J., Lauri Kaila, Ian J. Kitching, Niels P. Kristensen, David C. Lees, Joël Minet, Charles Mitter, Marko Mutanen, Jerome C. Regier, Thomas J. Simonsen, Niklas Wahlberg, Shen-Horn Yen, Reza Zahiri, David Adamski, Joaquin Baixeras, Daniel Bartsch, Bengt Å. Bengtsson, John W. Brown, Sibyl Rae Bucheli, Donald R. Davis, Jurate De Prins, Willy De Prins, Marc E. Epstein, Patricia Gentili-Poole, Cees Gielis, Peter Hättenschwiler,
Axel Hausmann, Jeremy D. Holloway, Axel Kallies, Ole Karsholt, Akito Y. Kawahara, Sjaak (J.C.) Koster, Mikhail V. Kozlov, J. Donald
Lafontaine, Gerardo Lamas, Jean-François Landry, Sangmi Lee, Matthias Nuss, Kyu-Tek Park, Carla Penz, Jadranka Rota, Alexander Schintlmeister, B. Christian Schmidt, Jae-Cheon Sohn, M. Alma Solis, Gerhard M. Tarmann, Andrew D. Warren, Susan Weller, Roman V. Yakovlev, Vadim V. Zolotuhin, Andreas Zwick
2011 Order Lepidoptera Linnaeus, 1758. In: Zhang, Z.-Q. (Ed.) Animal biodiversity: An outline of higher-level classification and survey of taxonomic richness. Zootaxa 3148:212–221.
VanPool, Christine S., and Todd L. VanPool. 1999: The Scientific Nature of Postprocessualism. American Antiquity 64(1):33–53.
2007 Signs of the Casas Grandes Shaman. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.
VanPool, T. L., and C. S. VanPool. 2003: Science and the Role of Evaluation in an Indigenous Archaeology. In Indigenous People and Archaeology: Proceedings of the 32nd Chacmool Conference, edited by T. Peck, E. Siegfried, and G. E. Oetelaar, pp. 69–81. University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
VanPool, T. L., and C. S. VanPool., Phillips, David A., editors. 2006: Religion in The Prehispanic Southwest. Lanham, Maryland: Altamira Press.
VanPool, Christine S., and Todd L. VanPool 2007: Signs of the Casas Grandes Shamans. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City.
Vitebsky, P. 1995: Shamanism. University of Oklahoma Press.
Weil, Andrew, T. 1977. Some Notes on Datura. Journal of Psychedelic Drugs 9(2): 165–69.